This time the uprising in Zimbabwe is different – but will it bring regime change?

Zimbabwe’s ruling Zimbabwe African National Union – Patriotic Front (ZANU-PF) has failed to develop sustainable institutions that could drive a more democratic vision of sovereignty and liberation. It has also been found lacking in creating a more consensual, hegemonic and much less coercive form of rule.



This failure has been central to the demands of dissenting voices and political organisations in the southern African state. It has also brought about a different type of protest against the Zimbabwean government.

Since the 2013 elections, convulsions within the ruling party have intensified to unprecedented levels. The recent protests in the public and informal sectors have exposed both the limits of ZANU-PF’s politics and the failure of its economic policies. The delays in payment of civil servants in June led to a widespread strike of teachers, health workers and other civil servants. The ruling party has managed for the time being to maintain payment to its security sector.

Who will the next president be?

Analytical commentary on Zimbabwe’s struggles has focused on the nature and causes of the contestations and centred mainly on the question of presidential succession. There are no clear answers to who will succeed an intransigent President Robert Mugabe, who has been in power since 1987.

Common to all the analyses is the challenge of stabilising and democratising the state by dealing both with the legacies of the colonial period and their new iterations in the post-colonial era.

This problem is not unique to Zimbabwe. It continues to haunt the state in post-colonial Africa, as it is forced to contend with the legacies of both structural inequalities and despotic forms of rule.

In Zimbabwe this problem has manifested itself in a centralised, authoritarian ruling party that has conflated its operations with those of the state.

Despite ongoing discussions with international financial institutions for new loans and budgetary support, this is unlikely to bring any respite in the near future. The funders are demanding certain conditions for any future loans. These include a credible repayment plan on past debt, security of property rights and certain reforms in governance. At present these demands are unlikely to be met.

Moreover, given the well-known effects of such conditions around debt repayment on developing countries, they would most likely exacerbate the crisis if they were implemented in the current context. Any substantive strategy on the way forward in Zimbabwe would require not only wide-ranging political reforms but also a new discussion on debt relief.

The challenges in the public sector have been compounded by a recent policy that has outraged the reportedly 94% of Zimbabweans who now make their living in the informal sector.

Anger from the informal sector

In June, the government promulgated Statutory Instrument 64, which banned the importing of a number of products that are traded in the informal sector. These include: coffee creamers, camphor creams, white petroleum jellies, body creams, baked beans, potato crisps, bottled water, mayonnaise, salad cream, peanut butter, canned fruit, cheese and many other items.

Most of these are products are sold by vendors in the now critically important informal sector. The sudden policy change, which was not subject to public discussion with those most affected by it, immediately incited considerable anger from the informal sector.

In the words of the chair of the National Vendor’s Union of Zimbabwe, Stern Zvorwadza: “The government is responsible for the poverty and pushing people into being vendors and cross-border traders, yet the same government is coming up with policies to stop people from earning an honest living at a time when they have killed the economy and failed to create jobs.”

The sheer lack of planning and callousness on the part of the state was clear to the Zimbabwean citizenry. In response to this policy and the abuse of numerous police road blocks to extort money from taxi drivers, the country experienced a mass stay-away in the first week of July.

At this stage it appears that the protest was organised through a number of new organisations, not tied to any political party, that use social media campaigns. These include Occupy Africa Unity Square, #ThisFlag and Tajamuka/Sesjikile.

Different type of activism

This movement is different to earlier forms of civic activism in a number of ways. First, it does not appear to be driven by any particular political party.

Second, since the demise of the structures of the labour movement in the first decade of the 2000s, the forms of organisation in the informal sector have become much more fluid. The result is that this form of activism is more difficult for the state to track, but it also makes such interventions more fragile and more difficult to sustain.

Third, the mode of protest appears to have drawn from forms used in South African protest movements. These include the burning of buildings, such as the torching of the Zimbabwe Revenue Service building at the Beit Bridge border between South Africa and Zimbabwe, and the burning of tyres in the streets.

This is not surprising given migration trends since 2000. Moreover there is much greater scepticism about the “rule of law” postulated by the state. This is viewed as an imposition by an authoritarian state which treats the populace as targets to be controlled, largely through the use of force.

Zimbabwe may be witnessing a change in the idea of citizenship. In the coming period it will be important to track not only the future of such activism but, just as importantly, the responses of the state beyond the current brutality of the police interventions.

• Brian Raftopoulos is a professor at the University of the Western Cape and the director of research and advocacy for Solidarity Peace Trust, an NGO working on Human Rights issues in Zimbabwe

• This article was originally published on The Conversation

Share this:

Arts & Entertainment

Arts & Entertainment

Damian Marley’s deep love for Africa

24th May 2017 Staff Reporter 0

Damian Marley’s 2010 collaboration album with Nas, Distant Relatives is littered with references to Africa’s rich cultural background. During the recording of the album Marley and Nas dug through archives of African music in search […]

3 Comments on This time the uprising in Zimbabwe is different – but will it bring regime change?

  1. aÅŸa este, dar e firesc să fim subiectivi, cum suntem ÅŸi când ne facem blogrol-ul…ÅŸi e destul de greu să clasezi, mai ales că majoritatea blogurilor pe care le citesc sunt multilateral orientate Cu multă plăcere!

  2. Great – I should definitely pronounce, impressed with your website. I had no trouble navigating through all tabs and related info ended up being truly simple to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it at all. Reasonably unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or anything, site theme . a tones way for your customer to communicate. Excellent task.

77 Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Robert Mugabe’s regime seeks parliamentary approval for bond notes as it faces legal minefield - Zimbabwe Consolidated News
  2. Google
  3. Google
  4. seibu edm filter
  5. dabs jar
  6. luxury watch trading
  7. vibrator
  8. Vibrator
  9. app for laptop
  10. laptop app
  11. Boudior
  12. games for pc download
  13. free full download for windows
  14. 100% kona coffee
  15. pure kona coffee
  16. pc games for windows 10
  17. miniclip 8 ball pool
  18. free download for windows 8
  19. penis enhancer
  20. Best Anal Plugs
  21. pc games full version download
  22. Vibrating Rabbit
  23. work at home jobs that are not scams
  24. Better Sex Toys
  25. Sell anything anywhere
  26. true wireless earbuds
  27. mulvadi kona coffee beans
  28. 100% pure mulvadi
  29. mulvadi 100% kona
  30. rotating g-spot rabbit vibrator
  31. ways to make money from home
  32. Παιδικό Δωμάτιο
  33. payday loans
  34. lace open back wedding dress
  35. wet rabbit
  36. thrusting silicone vibrator
  37. Stroker Kit
  38. sex doctor
  39. h natural oxford
  40. forex signal
  41. Search Engine
  42. G502
  43. persian tar
  44. gmc savana cargo van miami
  45. g vibe
  46. vibrator review
  48. butt plugs
  49. Buy Phentermine Without Prescription
  50. sexy
  51. recover files from sd card
  52. bedroom fengshui
  53. Grinders
  54. Cheap Kids Tampa Bay Lightning Jerseys
  55. 韓国エスコートアガシ
  56. casting for Flame Arrestor
  57. pc games for windows 8
  58. Tax
  59. motu and patlu games
  60. sexy
  61. Daytona beach Margaritaville
  62. Battery repair
  63. more movies
  65. Top Sex Toys
  66. oral surgery daytona
  67. denpasar
  68. First Birthday wishes
  69. Corsair Strafe vs K70,Cherry MX Silents
  70. Women Sex Toys
  71. Purchase Beer Online
  72. Soldier deployment boots
  73. women's health
  74. barcode kaufen
  75. buy email database uk
  76. gym shark
  77. old postcards

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.