The UK’s Economic Spiral Towards Zimbabwean-Style Monetary Policy

Canary wharf skyline

In Zimbabwe, where worthless $100 trillion (80.36 trillion pound) notes serve as reminders of the perils of hyperinflation, President Robert Mugabe is printing a new currency that jeopardizes not just the economy but his own long grip on power.

By Diane James MEP

Six months ago, the 92-year-old announced plans to address chronic cash shortages by supplementing the dwindling U.S. dollars in circulation over the past seven years with ‘bond notes’, a quasi currency expected at the end of November.” Reuters.

The good thing about being a dictator is that you can simply invent new money, wipe the slate clean, and get the economy working again. All you have to do is tell the Governor at the Central Bank to turn on the printing press and all your problems are solved. Except they aren’t; the currency will collapse, people will starve and you will be ejected from power.

For money to be worth anything it has to be backed by something. It acts as a medium to be held temporarily while goods and services are exchanged. The farmer sells his crops in return for money, which he then in turn exchanges for household items and capital goods when it is most efficient and appropriate for him/her to do so. In order for the system to work, the currency must have a reasonably static value, and a political system that guarantees this value. The currency is based upon these pillars. If the currency loses its static value then the trade in goods and services becomes chaotic, and the trust is broken.

Once the trust is established, money itself becomes a traded good subject to the same rigours of supply and demand as all the other goods and services. This trade in money comes in many shapes and forms including credit and insurance. The money markets become competitive in their own right, and the levels of interest or premium required fall, allowing the farmer to enjoy lower running costs. The key is the static value of the currency.

For many centuries money came in the form of gold and silver coins, both metals being rare and expensive to mine, yet still globally available. The supply of the coins was restricted by their scarcity, and so the value as a token of exchange was stable. Some people trimmed the coins and smelted the shavings to mint new ones. The ‘coin clippers’ were taking minute pieces from a multitude of coins to make new ones. The problem was that they were increasing the money supply, meaning that there were too many coins chasing too few commodities, food prices rose, and instability spread. The issue was so bad that in 1278 some 300 ‘coin clippers’ were arrested and executed at the Tower of London.

The problem, of course, is when the Government, like Mugabe’s, embarks upon its own ‘coin clipping.’ Governments, however, tend to clip coins on a grander scale. They switch on the presses and shower people with the new currency and hope for a return to stability, having wiped out the value of anything denominated in the old currency, like savings. Having seen the Government behave in such a reckless fashion terrifies the heck out of foreign investors, who pack up and never return. Or if they do return, it is at mind boggling interest rates.

Modern day coin clipping by the Governments comes in two main forms – debt accumulation, and Quantitative Easing – and a third ‘Helicopter Money’ is on the horizon.

Once the UK Government is unable (politically) to tax more, it borrows from the banks and the collateral is, of course, future tax revenues. The more it borrows the higher the interest rates charged by the banks will be. But the money that is lent by the banks is not money taken from deposits – it is new money (possibly ‘backed’ by around 3-5% deposits), and thus, the amount of money in circulation (the monetary base) increases. The more money in circulation, the higher prices will go. Yet this is in the interest of the Government, it actively seeks this inflation. It has debts set against a fixed rate of interest and the greater the money (or the higher the cost of money) in the market, the quicker it pays off its debts. But if the debt does not pare down the real value of the debt as planned (like 2008 onwards) it taxes more – typically on consumption, rather than income.

Once this fails, the Government invents new money (just like Mugabe) and tells the Bank of England to print new money. Since the onset of the financial crisis £430 billion in new ‘money’ has been created. Cynically the Government used this money to buy back its own debt, effectively lending to itself at zero interest rates, and reduce its interest payments (by about £10 billion a year) and make the public finances look better. This new money is recycled to the electorate in the form of mortgages, driving up house prices, or other consumer credit expanding, once again, the monetary base and driving up inflation. But it has driven down the real value (purchasing power) of the currency meaning that people become poorer in a more expensive world.

This Quantitative Easing, and it represents almost one third of the public debt, which has been put away on a shelf to be forgotten about. There are no plans ever to repay this debt, its sole aim was to ‘stimulate’ the economy, which really means make things become less affordable.

And inflation did bite making things less affordable.

We have all read the stories of house price inflation as prices for accommodation surpassed levels that caused the financial crisis.

Other basics like food also outstripped wage increases. Price increases for food ran up to double digits with the onset of QE, and hovered around 3-6% from 2010 until Q2 2014.

But wages did not match these cost increases in necessities, with wage increases barely ever reaching 2% according to the ONS.

How was this all paid for? Debt of course. Consumer credit has increased to almost £1.5 trillion in order to close the gap between wages and the cost of living. This means that there is now is 44% more money in circulation chasing the same amount of goods – most of it locked into mortgages or credit cards.

So the income inequality has actually been created by Government policy, aided and abetted by the Bank of England, as it has flooded the economy with money to pare down its debts. House prices, and other basics have gone up (household energy bills have also soared), but wages have stagnated. So, what is left for the Government to do? It will print even more money, of course.

The Scottish Government is considering issuing more ‘money’ into every household (as has been trialled in parts of the Netherlands and Finland) to stimulate demand. Everybody will get freshly printed notes and be instructed to go off and add to aggregate demand, i.e. spend. This is known as ‘Helicopter Money’. Of course, the problem of too much money chasing too few goods as the coin clipping takes steroids, and prices will soar again, across the board. But because we will not actually be making anything new, it will not be matched by real economic growth.

When that fails, what will the Government do then? It will do a Mugabe, rip up all the banknotes and start again with a new form of currency. What could possibly go wrong?

Related Posts
Building Africa’s Knowledge Economy
Development economists often differ with one another, but they agree on this: the knowledge economy will be the foundation of every nation’s progress in the twenty-first century. Yet while East ...
READ MORE
Bond notes: Will Mugabe come to rescue?
TWO things that are sure about death are its certainty and finality. Reference is being made to death in the physical sense, not the spiritual side of things. By Cyril Zenda Because ...
READ MORE
China’s growth ‘reassuring’ for ‘weak and vulnerable’ global economy: Xinhua
China will meet its growth target of 6.5 percent to 7 percent growth this year, a reassuring sign for a "weak and vulnerable" global economy, state news agency Xinhua said ...
READ MORE
Zimbabwe growth to quicken to 4.8 pct in 2017 – Treasury document
HARARE (Reuters) - Zimbabwe expects economic growth to quicken to 4.8 percent in 2017 from 1.2 percent this year on improved agriculture production and higher global commodity prices, the Treasury ...
READ MORE
‘It’s about trust not bond notes’
As government prepares to introduce bond notes, jittery ordinary Zimbabweans — including a large cross-section of impoverished women —say the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) has a herculean task of ...
READ MORE
Crisis and the meaning of money
Robert Mugabe Junior has the word “melanin” in his Instagram biography. I discovered this when I went to his profile, a little indulgence I allow myself every few weeks to ...
READ MORE
FILE - In this April 18, 2016 file photo, Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe delivers the key note address during Zimbabwe's 36th Independence day celebrations in Harare. Veterans of Zimbabwe's independence war made a significant break with President Mugabe for the first time on Thursday, July 21, 2016, calling him dictatorial, manipulative and egocentric. The Zimbabwe National Liberation War Veterans Association has been a pillar of support for the 92-year-old leader for decades, but it released a statement criticizing the man it had long been quick to defend. (AP Photo/Tsvangirayi Mukwazhi, File)
JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) - Human rights groups slammed the World Bank on Thursday over an internal report on Zimbabwe that suggested it would be a sign of "political development" for the ...
READ MORE
This year’s World Economic Forum in Davos will focus on the threat of right-wing populism for the first time ever
Each year in late January, around 2,000 of the globe’s leaders – politicians, bureaucrats, business representatives and public intellectuals – make the annual pilgrimage to the Swiss town of Davos ...
READ MORE
Stagnant economy, yawning deficit keep heat on Zimbabwe’s Mugabe
HARARE (Reuters) - Zimbabwe's economy has stagnated this year while its budget deficit has exploded, the government said on Thursday, adding to President Robert Mugabe's problems as he faces unprecedented ...
READ MORE
Zimbabwe’s year so far: a tale of regression
HARARE,– Zimbabwe has missed just about every major economic target so far this year, with most indicators pointing to an economy headed for recession, a local investment advisory firm has ...
READ MORE
Building Africa’s Knowledge Economy
Bond notes: Will Mugabe come to rescue?
China’s growth ‘reassuring’ for ‘weak and vulnerable’ global
Zimbabwe growth to quicken to 4.8 pct in
‘It’s about trust not bond notes’
Crisis and the meaning of money
World Bank accused of backing Zimbabwean tyrant
This year’s World Economic Forum in Davos will
Stagnant economy, yawning deficit keep heat on Zimbabwe’s
Zimbabwe’s year so far: a tale of regression

Arts & Entertainment