Moyo says there is no need to amend constitution, Mugabe already has powers to appoint judges

Higher Education Minister Jonathan Moyo, said to be one of the leaders of the G40 faction of the Zimbabwe African National Union-Patriotic Front, says it is ugly propaganda to say that the proposed amendment to the national constitution will empower the President to appoint the chief justice, deputy chief justice and the judge president because he already has that power.

The government has announced that it is amending the constitution, only adopted three years ago, to allow the President to appoint the three key judges and has stopped public interviews that were supposed to be conducted this month.

Four candidates had been short-listed but apparently one of the judges who is believed to be the party favourite was not among the four.

Sources say the judge was advised not to apply.

In a 10-point tweet, Moyo says while the constitution is amendable, any amendment should be based on truth, substantive reasons and public interest.

He says that the claim that section 180 of the constitution is a Movement for Democratic Change provision is false. Instead the proposed amendment is closer to MDC position.

The MDC COPAC position had the President nominating and approval was with Senate after confirmation hearing but this was rejected. Instead it was agreed to have transparency in all judiciary appointments.

The proposed amendment takes away transparency in the appointment of the chief justice, the deputy chief justice and judge president and controversially involves Senate, he argues.

“It’s ugly propaganda that proposed amendment will EMPOWER Pres to appoint CJ, DCJ & JP: he has that power now!” Moyo tweeted.

“Under proposed Amendment the same maligned JSC juniors will still recommend seniors BUT without transparency!

“It’s not right to embolden or create opposition to ZANU-PF in 2017 thru an unnecessary Constitutional Amendment!

“There’s no TRUTH, no SUBSTANTIVE REASON & no PUBLIC INTEREST warranting amendment of s180 of the Constitution!

“From 1999 to 2013 Zimbos were badly divided over a new Constitution. It’s wrong to bring those divisions back!”

Section 180 of the constitution clearly states that “The chief justice, the deputy chief justice, the judge president of the High Court and all other judges are appointed by the President in accordance with this section.”

Below is the section is full:

180  Appointment of judges

(1) The Chief Justice, the Deputy Chief Justice, the Judge President of the High Court and all other judges are appointed by the President in accordance with this section.

(2) Whenever the office of a judge referred to in subsection (1) is vacant or it is otherwise necessary to appoint such a judge, the Judicial Service Commission must—

(a)   advertise the position and invite applications;

(b)   invite the President and the public to make nominations;

(c)   conduct public interviews of prospective candidates;

(d)   prepare a list of three qualified persons as nominees for the office;  and

(e)   submit the list to the President;

whereupon, subject to subsection (3), the President must appoint one of the nominees to the office concerned.

(3) If the President considers that none of the persons on the list submitted to him in terms of subsection (2)(e) are suitable for appointment to the office, he or she must require the Judicial Service Commission to submit a further list of three qualified persons, whereupon the President must appoint one of the nominees to the office concerned.

(4) The President must cause notice of every appointment under this section to be published in the Gazette.

The Insider

Related Posts
Court protects prostitute from pimp
BULAWAYO – A self-confessed prostitute from Sauerstown in Bulawayo has been granted a protection order against her boyfriend who allegedly beat her up if she failed to bring money after ...
READ MORE
Moped rider who snatched 21 phones in hour-long theft spree is jailed
LONDON - A thief who snatched 21 phones in an hour while riding a moped has been jailed for three years and four months. Cavell Hutson, 21, and his accomplice, who ...
READ MORE
Worker fired for attending Gay party challenges dismissal
HARARE—In what could be a test case for the country, a former government employee, who was fired for allegedly engaging in gay practices, is suing the public service commission for ...
READ MORE
Traffic cops up the ante, seek access to offender bank accounts
Harare – Zimbabwean traffic authorities want access to offenders' bank accounts to ensure they pay their fines. The Zimbabwe Republic Police want to be able to garnish offenders' bank accounts so ...
READ MORE
Zimbabwe unlikely to get Cape house back
Harare - Zimbabwe will have a tough time trying to recover a property it owned in Cape Town which was sold by public auction on Monday. Although the courts had given ...
READ MORE
Holiday road accidents claim 81 lives
HARARE - The festive season has so far claimed 81 people after 3 more died in road accidents recorded on Saturday the 27th of December. The figure translates to an 8 ...
READ MORE
Zimbabwea mother jailed in UK for abducting her twins
A MOTHER who took her twin daughters out of the United Kingdom to Zimbabwe in defiance of a court order was starting an 18-month jail sentence Thursday. The woman - a ...
READ MORE
Businessman, Bredenkamp faces US$4m lawsuit
HARARE - Prominent business tycoon, John Arnold Bredenkamp faces a US$4 million lawsuit which commences tomorrow (Tuesday) in a pre-trial conference to be held at the High Court. Civil proceedings emanate ...
READ MORE
Mujuru bond note challenge thrown out
HARARE - Embattled Zimbabwe People First leader, Dr Joice Mujuru has lost her Constitutional Court challenge against President Robert Mugabe on the introduction of bond notes. In her court challenge, Dr ...
READ MORE
Police investigate knife found at O.J. Simpson’s onetime L.A. home
LOS ANGELES - Police said on Friday they were investigating a knife purportedly found at the former home of O.J. Simpson, the onetime football star who was acquitted of murdering ...
READ MORE
Court protects prostitute from pimp
Moped rider who snatched 21 phones in hour-long
Worker fired for attending Gay party challenges dismissal
Traffic cops up the ante, seek access to
Zimbabwe unlikely to get Cape house back
Holiday road accidents claim 81 lives
Zimbabwea mother jailed in UK for abducting her
Businessman, Bredenkamp faces US$4m lawsuit
Mujuru bond note challenge thrown out
Police investigate knife found at O.J. Simpson’s onetime

Arts & Entertainment